Repair Red Tape Is Making Housing Less Affordable

The job was to replace rotten panels around a crawlspace. Months later, the panels were still unfinished, winter was coming, and the owners were paying for heated tarpaulins.

That is the situation described in a British Columbia strata council’s update to its owners. The example comes from B.C., but every province should be asking whether its municipal permitting rules make ordinary housing repairs harder and more expensive than they need to be. These are the kinds of costs that get left out of the housing affordability discussion.

A repair becomes a permitting exercise

The crawlspace skirting was rotting at the bottom and letting rodents in. According to council, the plan was to replace it with the same thing. It was not load-bearing, and similar repairs had been done elsewhere in the complex without issue.

Once the panels came off, the contractor found rot in part of a post and beam beneath one home. Temporary reinforcement was installed, and a replacement beam was ordered.

A rotten beam needs proper attention. No argument there. But that does not explain why the owners were still learning which permits they needed months into the process.

Council set out the following timeline:

  • The municipality issued a stop-work order in early May.
  • A permit application covering the skirting and structural repairs was submitted in mid-June.
  • Nearly four weeks later, the municipality acknowledged the application and said it was still reviewing applications from April.
  • At the end of July, the strata was told the structural work needed a separate permit application.
  • In late August, two months after the first application, the municipality said the skirting work also needed a development permit.

The strata brought in further professional help to work through the requirements. The separate structural application went in at the end of September. By the end of October, that permit had been issued, although the repair was still waiting on the custom beam. The skirting work would have to wait until spring.

Meanwhile, the crawlspaces needed heated tarpaulins and extra heating to get through the winter.

All of this started with an attempt to replace rotten skirting and keep rodents out.

Why did the requirements come so late?

Of course the damaged beam needed an engineer, but why did it take months to tell the owners which permits to apply for?

Why was the need for a separate structural application raised at the end of July? Why did the development permit requirement emerge two months after the original application?

The strata disputed the development permit requirement and was trying to establish that the skirting repairs qualified for an exemption. Council’s update alone cannot settle who was right about that. But owners should be able to get a clear answer and challenge it if necessary without losing a repair season in the process.

The municipality was not responsible for every week that passed. Finding engineers, preparing applications, and obtaining a custom beam all took time too. That is precisely why permit requirements need to be clear from the start. There are already enough moving parts in a repair job without discovering another approval halfway through.

Housing affordability includes maintenance

Council expected the added engineering, drawings, permit work, discussions with the municipality, and fees to increase repair and maintenance costs by at least 30%. That was its estimate, not a final accounting. Even so, it is a substantial increase for owners to absorb.

And the permit fee is only part of it. Someone has to pay for the temporary protection, the heating, the extra professional time, and bringing contractors back. If the building deteriorates while everyone waits, owners pay for that too.

Council also reported that uncertainty over permits had prevented deck and balcony repairs that summer. It expected to have to plan future work much further ahead, even though some damage only becomes apparent after winter.

You cannot always plan a repair two years in advance. Sometimes you find the rot when you take the old material off.

These bills end up in strata or condominium fees and special levies or assessments. Putting the work off does not make the bill disappear. It can make it larger.

What provincial reform should require

Every province should set enforceable rules for municipal permitting of repairs to existing homes. The legislation and permit systems differ across the country, but the basic expectation should not: owners need clear requirements and timely decisions. Asking municipalities to cut red tape is not enough if owners have no way to get an answer.

A few changes would make a real difference:

Clear rules for routine repairs. An owner or contractor should be able to find out whether replacing a non-structural component with the same thing needs a permit. The rules should spell out the exceptions, including work affecting structure, fire safety, weather protection, or environmentally sensitive areas.

One coordinated list of approvals, provided early. Municipalities should have a deadline for identifying the permits and information a project needs. If another requirement comes up later, they should explain why it was not identified earlier or what has changed.

A faster process for urgent repairs. Structural deterioration and water entry cannot always wait in the same queue as other projects. There should be a way to approve necessary repairs promptly, with engineering oversight and inspections where needed. Heated tarpaulins should be a short-term precaution, not a winter maintenance plan caused by permitting delays.

Processing deadlines that mean something. Publish the deadlines and actual processing times. Separate time spent with the municipality from time spent waiting for information from the applicant. Give owners somewhere to escalate an application when it stalls.

A reasonable way to challenge a requirement. Owners should not have to contemplate a court proceeding just to get a timely review of whether a permit is needed.

None of this means approving unsafe work. It means making the process proportionate to the job and giving people an answer while there is still time to do the work.

Make it easier to look after existing homes

Building more housing matters. So does keeping the housing we have in good repair.

When a job that starts with rotten crawlspace panels ends with heated tarpaulins and a lost construction season, the process needs a hard look. Owners deserve to know what safety benefit each requirement delivers and why a decision takes as long as it does.

Every provincial government should be looking at this—and it should not just be seen as a municipal administration issue, but as part of the cost of housing.

People trying to maintain their homes should be able to get clear requirements, arrange the work, and get on with it. That should not be too much to ask.

Sign up for our news

Regulatory updates delivered as they happen.

Upcoming Webinars

No event found
join CAPL

Become a member

Stay informed with the latest industry insights.
Gain access to distinguished expert speaker webinars and our industry events.